Review Body:[Imported 2022-04-04 from mysupervisor.org (2022 archival dump, via pengp25/RateMySupervisor)]
类别: 其他
院系: Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering
【评价 1 · rate 2.5/5】
学术水平：Good at composite material. Knows nothing about battery. Can sometimes publish good work including AFM, NanoLetters, AEM.
科研经费：Has some funding. Students need to pay for utilities on their own, say nitro-gloves.
师生关系：Doing research in his lab is tough. No report no negative results are allowed. He sometimes dislikes a student for no reason. I heard that when one of his PhD refuses to do a post-doc in his lab, he refuses to let him graduate.
学生前途：Some of his student go to Germany to do post-doc.
【评价 2 · rate 3.8/5】
学术水平：Prof. Kim is an expert in composite mechanics and has extensive knowledge in functional composite as well. He also has a research direction of battery. It\'s worth noting that although he was not major in this area during his PhD study, he can still manage to learn all the basic knowledge in terms of the battery research and has no problem guiding the daily research and managing the future research direction of his students. He always review students\' manuscripts in detail and helps to polish the English and structure of the manuscripts quite well before submission to a peer reviewed journal, which is commendable because not so many chair Professors are willing to do that. You are certainty difficult to publish paper on journals like Nature or Science in his group but you can get your works published in top journals like AEM, AFM, ACS Nano etc. as long as you work hard. Therefore, he should get a high rating in this section.
科研经费：His research funding is not so much compared to other chair Professors. With the funding, you can do daily experiments and basic characterizations for your research without any problem. There\'s certainly no doubt to get your salary paid each month. Still, you can\'t spend money as much as you want on buying expensive experimental equipment so you need to rely on the existing equipment most of the time, which is fairly enough if you don\'t plan to do something really big.
师生关系：All the relations between the students and Prof. Kim is about academics. He will not interfere your personal affairs. You will have no problem to graduate on time as long as you meet the standard regarding academics. Sometimes students have arguments with him (i.e. whether or not to do Post-doc) but finally they still can graduate on time. In other words, personal grudges have nothing to do with academics, focus on your own research and everything will run smoothly.
学生前途：You will get a good training regarding academics when you graduate in this group so that you are pretty suitable to find a Professorship. However, there\'s no good connection between this group and the enterprise/industry. You may rely on your own to explore your future if you choose a career in industry instead of academics. There are alumnus working as Professor at both HK and mainland China. Also I\'ve heard about individuals chose to work beyond academics but not so often. One of them found a job in Apple many years ago.
【评价 3 · rate 1.0/5】
自证认识导师：韩国人…跟同系吴景深为师兄弟关系……但是两人完全没有联系……
学术水平：学生push的好，文章差不了…全身心投在文章上…
师生关系：连msc都卡的人……对你没看错是msc……跟学生关系差那是机械系都知道的事……这方面可以排第一……无理由dis你
【评价 4 · rate 1.8/5】
导师辨识特征：韩国人，高个子
学术水平：搞材料的，灌水文章一大堆
科研经费：全靠RGC的支持，科研经费少，精打细算
学生补助：正常
师生关系：出了名的mean和push啊，Msc都延毕的老师，MPhil和phd那不都得跪了；每天就想着发高分的文章，push学生发，毕业要求就是文章数量和影响因子
工作时间：很长
学生前途：学术界如今科大毕业没啥前途，慢慢沦为二流学校了，尤其乱港分子一闹，以后更悲催了。工业界，香港没啥工业，研究方向也没啥工业前景，水文章而已
Overall:2: Below average - Several meaningful concerns; proceed with caution.
Mentoring:2: Below average - Often unavailable, or feedback is thin / unhelpful.
Research Guidance:2: Below average - Weak taste or frequently flip-flopping priorities.
Funding:2: Below average - Frequent funding pressure that affects the work.
Work-Life Balance:2: Below average - Often expects long hours or weekend work.
Career Support:2: Below average - Letters or connections are weak or limited.
Official Review by mysupervisor-dump-2022