Francesco Ciucci

香港科技大学
  • Reviews: 1 · Overall: 3.00 / 5

1 Reviews

Official Review by mysupervisor-dump-2022

Other Reviewby mysupervisor-dump-2022 2022-04-04
Review Body:[Imported 2022-04-04 from mysupervisor.org (2022 archival dump, via pengp25/RateMySupervisor)] 类别: 其他 院系: Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering 【评价 1 · rate 0.0/5】 学术水平:He did modeling during his PhD but he is supervising students on experimental materials science. He can publish some relatively good work. 科研经费:He has some funding and it seems he is getting more. 师生关系:He appears caring about student but he turns quickly for no reason. Quoting from his student what he said: "why should I care?" 学生前途:I heard some of the students may be able to find a position on their own after some struggle but do not expect to get any help from him. He can/will NOT recommend a student to a top-notch group/good academic position. I also heard that when his student refuses to do a post-doc in his lab, he delayed his graduate for several month. 【评价 2 · rate 5.0/5】 导师辨识特征:He is very handsome and very charming. Many students and young teachers in mainland love him. 学术水平:He think he is number one in the world. 科研经费:He seems to have a lot of funding... 学生补助:Very high in Hong Kong (but every PhD gets the same amount) 师生关系:Why should I care??? 工作时间:Work harder, harder, and harder... 学生前途:Professors in Universities. You should do your best to find a job. It\'s hard to get his recommendation letter to support you. Do it yourself. Why should I care?
Overall:3: Average - Mixed experience; depends on the student’s profile and needs.
Mentoring:3: Average - Neither hands-on nor fully hands-off; passable.
Research Guidance:3: Average - Mix of hits and misses; student drives a lot of the direction.
Funding:3: Average - Funding covers essentials; some uncertainty.
Work-Life Balance:3: Average - Demanding but sustainable if you set your own limits.
Career Support:3: Average - Does the minimum; won’t push exceptionally.
Add: